Mehmet Cemal Azmi Bey (1868-1922) was a gifted bureaucrat and very efficient in the performance of his duties. He had been twice decorated for the services he provided to the army during the war and even rewarded with an honorary military rank. Career and public service were certainly more important to him than ideology.
According to the Chrysanthos, Archbishop of Athens (1881-1949), who by his own admission was Cemal Azmi Bey’s sincere friend, the latter “was in essence an ‘Old-Turk’ [παλαιότουρκος: attached to the Empire’s traditional principles] who became a Young-Turk, because only as such he could prevail and act”. In fact Cemal Azmi was a late member of the Committee of Union and Progress (CUP). It is from 1913 onwards that he developed strong ties with the CUP leaders for having actively participated in the coup of 23 January 1913, called the “Raid on the Sublime Porte”. These ties made of Cemal Azmi both a powerful governor and a docile organ of the committee.
Before the war, Cemal Azmi served as sub-district governor (kaymakam) and district governor (mutasarrıf) in different places in Anatolia and especially in the Balkans. When he was the kaymakam of Avrethisar/Kilkis (1902-1907), he headed an inquiry commission concerning the violent repression of the Ilinden Uprising (1903) in the sub-district (kaza) of Razlog, thereby contributing to the acquittal of his fellow Kaymakam of Razlog, Hasan Tahsin Bey (1870-1934), who was known as Uzer after 1934, and was later governor of Erzurum.
Governor of Trebizond↑
Cemal Azmi Bey was named governor of Trebizond on 29 July 1914: the day after the beginning of the Great War and four days before the ratification of the secret Ottoman-German Alliance (2 August 2 1914). The province of Trebizond – along with that of Erzurum – was situated on the Ottoman-Russian border and was therefore expected to play a crucial role in the upcoming war. Mehmed Talat Bey (1874-1921) and the CUP’s civil faction wanted to have a trusted person there and Cemal Azmi Bey, a putschist of the “Raid on the Sublime Porte”, had the required credentials.
During his first month in Trebizond, Cemal Azmi was joined by different members of the notorious Ottoman Special Organization (Teşkilat-ı Mahsusa). Being initiated into the organization, he put all of the vilayet’s facilities at the service of its paramilitary activities. Cemal Azmi’s arrival in Trebizond started his relationship of good understanding and close collaboration with the Orthodox Metropolitan Chrysanthos. As the latter recalls in his memoirs, due to his advice the vali adopted a series of measures which protected the Greek Orthodox of Trebizond from the hardships of the war. These measures, Chrysanthos wrote, “were the fruit of the good relations that I meticulously developed with the vali Cemal Azmi Bey, whom I liked very much for his natural behavior, his somehow savage nature and for his willingness to accept all of my legal requests”.
During the Armenian Genocide↑
The positive portrait of Cemal Azmi drawn by Chrysanthos is at odds with the testimonies concerning the role played by him in the Armenian genocide. Cemal Azmi was tried in absentia in 1919 in Istanbul for the Armenian massacres of 1915. According to the tribunal’s verdict:
According to the verdict’s text, the deported Armenians left the city escorted by gendarmes and criminals. When they moved away from the city, the men were separated from the women and were robbed and savagely murdered by bands formed by people similar to the convoys’ escorts. The bandits stole women’s jewellery and committed mass rapes.
This account is confirmed by the memories of the Armenian survivors as well as by Muslim witnesses, foreign observers and Greek Orthodox sources. Additionally, the deported Armenians were systematically massacred in the entire sub-districts of the vilayet of Trebizond. Apparently, Cemal Azmi Bey aimed to ensure that the above-mentioned “secretly transmitted orders” should be strictly applied by all the officials under his orders. As for the origin of these “secret orders”, according to the Metropolitan Chrysanthos as well as to Muslim witnesses and Armenian survivors, they were transmitted to Cemal Azmi and to Yenibahçeli Nail Bey (?-1926) by Bahaeddin Şakir (1874-1922), a member of CUP’s Central Bureau who arrived in Trebizond a few days before the deportations and massacres and had long meetings with Cemal Azmi and Yenibahçeli Nail.
Trebizond was occupied by the Russians on 18 April 1916. When leaving Trebizond, before the advancing Russian Army, Cemal Azmi entrusted Chrysanthos with the city’s temporary government. On that occasion, Chrysanthos recalls, Cemal Azmi pronounced the following grandiloquent words: “We took this city from the Greeks and we are giving it back to them”. Subsequently he transferred the province’s siege to the non-occupied town of Ordu.
After leaving Trebizond, Cemal Azmi’s attitude towards the Greek Orthodox was modified. At the end of 1916 the Ottoman Third Army ordered the displacement of the Greek Orthodox population of the sub-districts of Tirebolu and Giresun, next to the new frontline. Then, during the first months of 1917, a controversy occurred between Cemal Azmi and the Third Army commander, Mehmed Vehip Pasha (1877-1940), concerning the displacement of the Greek Orthodox population of the city of Giresun itself (some 12,000 to 14,000 people). Eager to displace these people, Cemal Azmi and his confidantes in Giresun had gone far beyond the law. The Greek Orthodox protested and an inquiry was opened, confirming the abuses.
Personally offended, Cemal Azmi tried to launch a witch hunt against the Greek Orthodox of Giresun and their alleged protector, Vehip Pasha, but to no avail. Due to the martial law, the local power lay at that point with the army command and not with the public administration. Cemal Azmi’s shift of attitude towards the Greek Orthodox is reminiscent of Tahsin Bey’s (Uzer) attitude toward the Ottoman Armenians. During his governorship of Van, Tahsin Bey appeared friendly and accommodating towards the Armenian representatives and political leaders. However, once installed as the new vali in Erzurum in late 1914, Tahsin followed Talaat’s instructions and cooperated with the leaders of the Special Organization based in Erzurum, thus paving the way to the genocide.
Cemal Azmi’s Last Years↑
Finally, on 26 July 1917, the three non-occupied sub-districts of the province of Trebizond (Tirebolu, Giresun and Ordu) had been annexed to the administratively independent district (sancak) of Canik. Therefore the existence of the vilayet of Trebizond remained only nominal and Cemal Azmi Bey was not given a new administrative post. Feeling frustrated, he retired from public service and, in the spring of 1918, he migrated with his family to Berlin. There he kept a tobacco shop, which became a meeting place for the CUP leaders who fled to Berlin after the Armistice of Mudros (30 October 1918) such as Talat and Bahaeddin Şakir. He did not participate in Ismail Enver Pasha’s (1881-1922) post-war pan-Turkist endeavours. He was tried in absentia and was sentenced to death on May 1919 in Istanbul for the murder and relocation of the Armenians of Trebizond. Cemal Azmi Bey was assassinated in 1922 in Berlin’s Uhlandstraße together with Bahaeddin Şakir by two Armenian revolutionaries, as part of the Operation Nemesis.
Nikos Sigalas, L'École des hautes études en sciences sociales
Section Editor: Erol Ülker
- Χρύσανθος (Αρχιεπίσκοπος Αθηνών) [Chrysanthos (Archbishop of Athens)]: Βιογραφικαὶ ἀναμνήσεις [Memoires], Athens 1970, p. 92.
- Ibid., pp. 101-102.
- Akçam, Taner / Dadrian, Vahakn N. (eds.): “Tehcir ve taktil”. Divan-ı Harb-i Örfi Zabıtları. İttihad ve Terakki’nin Yargılanması 1919-1922 [“Forced Displacement and Killings”. Court-Martial’s Minutes. The Trials of Union and Progress 1919-1922], Istanbul 2010, p. 706.
- Χρύσανθος [Chrysanthos], Ἀναμνήσεις [Memoires], 1970, pp. 126-127.
- Çankaya, Ali: Yeni Mülkiye tarihi ve Mülkiyeliler (New history of the school of public administration and the school’s alumni), volume 3, Ankara 1968: Ankara Üniversitesi Siyasal Bilgiler Fakültesi.
- Kaiser, Hilmar: Tahsin Uzer. The CUP’s man in the East, in: Bayraktar, Seyhan / Schmutz, Thomas; Kieser, Hans-Lukas et al. (eds.): The genocide of 1915 and the politics of Turkish nationalism, London 2019: I.B. Tauris, pp. 93-116.
- Kévorkian, Raymond H.: The Armenian genocide. A complete history, London 2011: I. B. Tauris.
- Sigalas, Nikos: L’occupation de Trabzon et la formation de la question pontique, in: Drieu, Cloé / Mouradian, Claire (eds.): Enjeux d’empires et de nations sur le front caucasien. Regards neufs sur un front oublié de la Grande Guerre (forthcoming), Paris (forthcoming): CNRS Éditions.
- Sigalas, Nikos: How the displacement of Giresun’s Romei has been avoided. An inquiry about the politics of the rear front, the state and society during World War I, in: Beşikçi, Mehmet / Somel, Akşin / Toumarkine, Alexander (eds.): Not all quiet on the Ottoman fronts. Neglected perspectives on a global war, 1914-1918, Baden-Baden 2020: Ergon, pp. 165-198.
- Uzer, Tahsin: Makedonya Eşkiyalık Tarihi ve Son Osmanlı Yönetimi (History of Banditism in Macedonia and the late Ottoman administration), Ankara 1999: Turk Tarih Kurumu Basimevi.