Polish War Myths (East Central Europe)

By Paweł Brudek

1914-1918 Online

Internal Encyclopedia of the First World War

This text is licensed under Creative Commmons Licence

(Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Germany-CC BY-NC-ND 3.0)

Table of Contents

- 1 Introduction

- 2 The March of the First Cadre Company on 6 August 1914

- 3 The First Cadre Company: Myth and Reality

- 4 The Role of the First Brigade of the Legions in the Reconstruction of Independent Poland

- 5 Debate about the First World War in Interwar Poland 1918-1939

- 6 Conclusion

- Notes

- Selected Bibliography

- Citation

1 Introduction

The political crisis which had been growing in Europe since the First Balkan War in 1912, favoured the plans of Polish national movement. Józef Piłsudski (1867-1935), previously a Russian prisoner in Siberian exile, planned to organize Polish military squads within the Austro-Hungarian army, counting on the outbreak of a Polish uprising in the Polish Kingdom caused by war between Austria-Hungary and Russia. On the eve of the Great War, Galicia became the base for Polish independence activity.

2 The March of the First Cadre Company on 6 August 1914

On 30 July 1914, Józef Piłsudski announced, with the acceptance of the Austrian command, the mobilisation of the Riflemen Squads, expecting war to erupt quickly between Austria and Russia. He planned to invade the Kingdom of Poland with the Riflemen and provoke the outbreak of an uprising against Russian rule. For Piłsudski, complete success would have meant the occupation of Warsaw before the Central Powers’ armies could arrive. He also wanted to announce the establishment of the National Government in Warsaw. On 3 August in Cracow, the First Cadre Company was formed from 144 riflemen (mainly students). Piłsudski defined them in his short speech as “Polish soldiers,” revealing their future task: the creation of cadres for a Polish army. On 6 August 1914, the Habsburg monarchy declared war on Russia. The First Company marched from Cracow towards the Austro-Russian border and entered the Kingdom of Poland.[1]

The territorial base for the development of Polish statehood was situated in the area between the Austrian border and the city of Kielce which had been in the Russian partition. Forming an army was to be the first stage in the process of reconstructing Poland. In the independent “Piłsudski’s state” one principle took first place, which Piłsudski had announced in his officers briefing: to proceed as if the Austrian power did not exist.[2] Despite the Russian conquest and devastation of Kielce on 12 August, the expected uprising against Russian rule did not happen due to fear of Russian vengeance.

Facing the early failure of the plan to provoke a Polish uprising, the Austrian authorities soured on the idea of Piłsudski’s Riflemen and demanded their disbanding. However, the Riflemen were saved by the quick action of Galician politicians, who on 16 August announced the creation of the Chief National Committee (Naczelny Komitet Narodowy, or NKN). This group filled the role of political representation for the Polish forces, which could exist in the form of so-called “Legions” subordinated to Austria. Two legions came into being – the eastern legion in Lwów and the western legion in Cracow. Piłsudski took over the command in the first regiment, later known as the First Brigade of the Legions.

3 The First Cadre Company: Myth and Reality

Legion myth portrayed Piłsudski’s soldiers as exiles who were forced by the Russians to leave their homeland – the Kingdom of Poland – like Piłsudski himself. Supported by their comrades from Galicia, they returned as heroes of the fight for Polish independence.[3] For propaganda purposes, Piłsudski exaggerated the difficulties caused by his powerful enemies. In Piłsudski’s opinion, the company had been badly armed and equipped. According to the reminiscences of one of its members, however, this was not so. The equipment, stores of ammunition, and the complete uniform (the grey rifleman’s summer uniform), distinguished the First Cadre Company from other units.[4] Piłsudski’s propaganda contrasted the Riflemen – as the leaders of the fight for Polish independence – with the silent and passive majority of Polish society, which did not want to risk actively opposing Russian tsarism. The liberation of Kielce became a symbol of the loneliness of the Riflemen heroes ignored by their fellow countrymen who closed their shutters instead of welcoming the Polish soldiers. The reality was considerably more complicated, though the symptoms of reluctance towards the Riflemen were visible.

The First Company became the foundation for the cadres of the future Polish army. Thirteen of its soldiers attained the rank of general between 1918 and 1945. The formation also distinguished itself with its predominant number of recruits from the intelligentsia. The large number of poets among the Riflemen helped to create its own legend. The image of the Riflemen highlighted youth and energy and announced a glowing vision of the future Polish state.[5]

4 The Role of the First Brigade of the Legions in the Reconstruction of Independent Poland

In the years 1914–1916 about 30,000 to 35,000 of the First Brigade soldiers served on the front lines of World War One. Thanks to the Legions Piłsudski became the true leader, whose important role was fully valued in Berlin and Vienna. He knew that the most important thing was to minimise Polish losses as their sacrifice would not improve the political position of Poland. Piłsudski supported the idea of the Legions until the Russians had been visibly defeated. When he changed his attitude towards the Central Powers at the end of 1916, he began to liquidate the Legions as they were formations that could be used by the Austrians and Germans to influence Polish politics.

Legion legend portrayed the effectiveness of Piłsudski’s faction in the fight against the torpor and passivity of Polish society during the First World War. The Legions were said to have shattered indifference, teaching the Poles to think and act as patriots again. The unusual fate of the Legions and their commandant seemed to confirm the truth of the myth. Piłsudski was arrested and imprisoned in Germany where he could only wait for a better future. The remaining legionnaires were imprisoned in internment camps or were conscripted into the Austro-Hungarian army. This defeat was transformed into total victory with the collapse of the Central Powers in the autumn of 1918. It caused the rapid end of the occupation and the rebirth of Poland.

5 Debate about the First World War in Interwar Poland 1918-1939

Though in 1920 Piłsudski had already been designated as a “Great Builder of Our Motherland,” it was only in the second half of the decade when cult expressions, such as “Builder of Poland,” “Resuscitator of Poland,” “Creator of Polish freedom,” and “Creator of Independence,” predominated. The history of the fight for independence was dominated by Józef Piłsudski and the First Brigade, which diminished the role of the Second Brigade, the First Polish Corps of Józef Dowbor-Muśnicki (1867-1937) and the “Blue Army” of General Józef Haller (1873-1960).[6] Their fight for Poland’s freedom was incomparable to the First Brigade’s achievement.

Before the May coup d’état of 1926 in Poland there was further discussion about the process of regaining independence. The social response to the legionary tradition was ambiguous. In the years 1933-1934 there was a dispute about the words of the “First Brigade” song. Piłsudski’s followers wanted to include these lyrics to the national anthem Jeszcze Polska nie zginęła, but they were not successful. 6 August – the day of the First Cadre Company’s departure from Cracow in 1914 – became a holiday exclusively for Piłsudski’s followers. The celebration was directed only at the combatants of the First Brigade, without the veterans of the Second and Third Brigades of the Legions.[7] There was an additional dispute about the proper date of Polish independence which was not celebrated until 1926. Until the end of the Second Polish Republic in 1939, the memory of the events from the years 1914-1918 divided society more than united it.

6 Conclusion

After the rebirth of the Polish state on 11 November 1918, Józef Piłsudski filled the role of the temporary chief of state of Poland. The years between 1918 and 1920, as well as between 1926 and 1935, when Piłsudski filled the role of leader of the new state were also the years of the reconstruction of a new Polish historical consciousness. The myth of the leading and solitary role of Piłsudski’s legionnaires, which underestimated other military units, not only simplified and falsified the view of the latest events in 1914-1918, but also built a narrow picture of the whole 19th century. Given such a situation, Piłsudski’s legend quickly found its opponents who countered with the role of the leaders of National Democracy – Roman Dmowski (1864-1939) and other Polish military commanders such as Dowbor-Muśnicki or Haller in the decisive battles for the freedom of the state. This discussion lasted until the outbreak of the Second World War and deeply divided the political elites and society.

Paweł Brudek, Museum of Warsaw Uprising

Section Editors : Ruth Leiserowitz; Theodore Weeks

Notes

1. ↑ Garlicki, Andrzej: Introduction, in: Piłsudski, Józef: Moje pierwsze boje [My first fights], Lódz 1988, p. 11; Sobieski, Wacław: Dzieje Polski [The History of Poland], vol.1: 1864-1938, edited and completed by Stanisław Kozicki, Warsaw 1938, p. 132; Moczulski, Leszek:Przerwane powstanie polskie 1914 [The interrupted Polish Uprising 1914], Warsaw 2010, p. 203; Suleja, Włodzimierz: Kosynierzy i strzelcy. Rzecz o irredencie [The Kosynierzy – Scythe Bearers – and Riflemen. The Question of irredenta], Wrocław 1997, p. 198; Englert, Juliusz and Nowik, Grzegorz: Marszałek Józef Piłsudski. Komendant - Naczelnik Państwa - Pierwszy Marszałek Polski [Marshal Józef Piłsudski. Commander – Chief of state – The First Marshal of Poland], Warsaw 2007, p. 34.

2. ↑ Pelczarski, T.: Komisariaty Wojskowe Rządu Narodowego w Królestwie Polskim 6 VIII - 5 IX 1914 [The Military Commission of the National Government in the Polish Kingdom 6 VIII – 5 IX 1914], Warsaw 1939, p. 131, quoted in: Urbankowski, Bohdan: Józef Piłsudski. Marzyciel i strateg [Jóżef Piłsudski. Dreamer and Strategist], vol. 1, Warsaw 1997, p. 193.

3. ↑ Urbankowski, Piłsudski 1997, pp. 155, 165, 189.

4. ↑ Piłsudski, Józef: Pisma Wybrane, London 1943, p. 61, quoted in: Englert and Nowik, Marszałek 2007, p. 34; Englert, Adam Wicenty “Judym”: Wspomnienia, in: Strzelec 31 (1934), pp. 15-19, quoted in: Englert and Nowik, Marszałek 2007, p. 38.

5. ↑ Moczulski, Przerwane powstanie 2010, pp. 742-744; Urbankowski, Piłsudski 1997, pp. 172-173, 177, 181,186.

6. ↑ Cichoracki, Piotr: Z nami jest on : Kult Marszałka Józefa Piłsudskiego w Wojsku Polskim w latach 1926–1939 [He is with us. The Cult of Marshal Józef Piłsudski in the Polish Army in the years 1926-1939], Wrocław 2001, pp. 7, 31-32, 37-38; Hein-Kircher, H.: Kult Piłsudskiego i jego znaczenie dla państwa polskiego 1926-1939 [The Cult of Piłsudski and its meaning for the Polish state 1926-1939], Warsaw 2008, pp. 195, 228-229, 231.

7. ↑ Hein-Kircher, Kult Piłsudskiego 2008, p. 192.

Citation

Brudek, Paweł: Polish War Myths (East Central Europe) , in: 1914-1918-online. International Encyclopedia of the First World War, ed. by Ute Daniel, Peter Gatrell, Oliver Janz, Heather Jones, Jennifer Keene, Alan Kramer, and Bill Nasson, issued by Freie Universität Berlin, Berlin 2014-10-08. DOI: 10.15463/ie1418.10793.

License

This text is licensed under Creative Commmons Licence (Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Germany-CC BY-NC-ND 3.0)

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

Introduction

The March of the First Cadre Company on 6 August 1914

The First Cadre Company: Myth and Reality

The Role of the First Brigade of the Legions in the Reconstruction of Independent Poland

Debate about the First World War in Interwar Poland 1918-1939

Conclusion

Selected Bibliography

Citation

Content